Estadao, Brazil

Rhetoric Triumphs Over Reality in Latin America


"The creation of the Community of Latin American and Caribbean States reflects the disorientation of the region's governments, locked as they are in the illusion that snubbing the United States will do for Latin American integration what 200 years of history failed to do."




Translated By Brandi Miller


February 25, 2010


Brazil - Estadao - Original Article (Portuguese)

"The ideal of Bolívar, a united America, still lives ... It's more alive than ever" -- Mexican President Felipe Calderón. "We can say that the dream of Simon Bolívar has come true" -- Venezuelan President Hugo Chávez. "Historically transcendent" -- Cuban President Raúl Castro. "A historic fact of great significance." -- Brazilian President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva.


Even by good neighborly standards, there is a heartbreaking contrast between the rhetoric pouring out to welcome the creation of a new multilateral entity in the region, and its more than obvious limitations for integrating, "one and only one American nation, united in its values of democracy, justice and equality," as recited by Calderón.


He and 31 other heads of State and government met for two days in Cancún for the Latin America and Caribbean Summit and signed the birth certificate for an entity that the Venezuelan [Chavez] wanted call the Organization of Latin American States to distinguish it from the Organization of American States, which is controlled by the "empire." But the Mexican [Calderón], the father of this shoot, preferred the Union of Latin American and Caribbean States. On the suggestion of Brazil, the first word was substituted with the more modest "Community," which resulted in the acronym CLACS (Community of Latin American and Caribbean States). This is yet another contribution to a prolific regional alphabet for naming political initiatives, the effectiveness of which varies inversely with the swagger of how they are advertised.


In no passage of the thick 88 pages that attests to Community's arrival in the world, which is the fruit of the connection between CALC (the Latin American and Caribbean Summit) and the Rio Group (a consultative mechanism with 18 member states created in 1986 - also without U.S. participation), is there a description of what its structure and function will be. These details, as well as the statutes of the Community, will be decided at the next meeting of CLACS, set for July 2011 in Caracas. If Lula wants it, the presidency of the unformed body could be his. Chávez has already proposed his name, with Calderón welcoming him as the, "undisputed leader of our region." The Brazilian didn't want to say goodbye to his peers, reminding them that he would meet with them "in many forums" before December 31st - an unintentional reminder of the wealth of opportunities that remain to praise one another - or to exchange insults, as happened recently - and to stick their tongues out at the Americans.




La Razon, Bolivia: Latin America Has Excluded the U.S. … So What Now?

ABC, Spain: Hugo Chavez Calls Terrorism Indictment a U.S.-Spanish Plot  

Folha, Brazil: Latin American Unity Cannot Be Dependent on Excluding the U.S.  

La Jornada, Mexico: Latin America's March Toward 'Autonomy from the Imperial Center'

La Jornada, Mexico: Militarization of Latin America: Obama 'Ahead of Bush'

O Globo, Brazil: U.S. Navy Shows That What U.S. Can Do, Brazil Can Also Do  

Clarin, Argentina: Resurrected U.S. Fourth Fleet Creates Suspicion Across South America

Le Figaro, France: U.S. Navy 'Resurrects' Fourth Fleet to Patrol Latin America

Semana, Colombia: Hugo Chávez Isn't 'Paranoid' to Fear the U.S. Marines


Bookmark and Share


To this can be add Chávez' Bolivarian Alliance for the Americas (ALBA) and, to some extent, the Union of South American Nations (UNASUL). The recently-created OAS of Brazil [a nickname for the Community of Latin American and Caribbean States], as it has inevitably been called, bars entry to the United States and Canada and opens its doors to Cuba, which was excluded from the original OAS.


This appears to be their only reason for being, aside of course from serving as a stage for diplomatic songs of protest and parades of Guayabera shirts - the official uniform of the new entity. In Cancún, the highlight of the show was the unanimous condemnation of oil exploration by a British company off the coast of the Falkland Islands. Amidst all the commotion, Lula raised his voice against the United Nations for not supporting claims Argentina has had over the islands since the 19th century. According to Lula, the U.N. favors the United Kingdom because of its permanent seat on the U.N. Security Council - the greatest ambition of Lula's foreign policy.   



Presented as a reason for the emergence of CLACS, the assertion of sovereignty and the quest to integrate its 33 heterogeneous members (32 that were present in Cancún, and when it's rehabilitated, Honduras) this represents a triumph of rhetoric over regional reality. It ignores conflicts such as the one between Venezuela and Colombia - Chávez and Álvaro Uribe traded insults at the summit - and the friction between Argentina and Uruguay, to name only the most notorious. "We were barely able to implement UNASUL, which is restricted to South America - a clear geopolitical unit," observes political scientist Ricardo Sennes. "Imagine an institution that encompasses all of Latin American. What will its identity be?"


CLACS reflects the disorientation of the region's governments in relation to its problematic environment and its lack of foreign policy direction, locked as it is into the illusion that snubbing the United States will do for Latin American integration what 200 years of history failed to do. Although not a creature of Brazil, CLACS fits into the model of Lula's diplomacy and its obsession with harassing the "Whites with blue eyes."



blog comments powered by Disqus


































[Posted by WORLDMEETS.US, Mar. 3, 5:09pm]


Bookmark and Share